How to Pick the Best Sheets for Your Mattress

How to Pick the Best Sheets for Your Mattress

Finding the ideal bed sheets can be both a complex decision and a significant investment.

In the wide world of bedding—for its conjuring up imagery of an anthropomorphized nightcap-wearing full moon sleepily smile-and-winking your way as you drift by on somehow benevolent clouds intent on hugging you gently to sleep—choosing the right set of sheets can in the waking world feel like navigating a bit of maze. With an abundance of options spanning various fabrics, thread counts, designs (etc.), finding those ideal sheets can be both a complex decision and a significant investment.

But fret not, all you (would-be? desperately-hope-to-be?) dreamers. Instead, read along below, where we’ve compiled all the essential info you’ll need for picking the very best sheets for your mattress—i.e., for you.

Cracking the Thread Count Code

Thread count, often flaunted on sheet labels, is a critical bit of selection criteria; it measures/indicates the density of fibers woven into each square inch of fabric. In simple terms, a higher thread count usually translates to smoother, more durable sheets, albeit at a bit of a premium. However, it’s important not to get myopically fixed by this number (i.e., the thread count), as it can sometimes be misleading in consideration of potential blending of various cotton fibers. (A mattress professional can always clarify!)

Selecting the Right Fabric

While the impact of bedding fabrics on sleep quality is undeniable, alas, although it would simplify things there no one-size-fits-all solution. Cotton sheets, with their vaunted breathability and moisture-wicking properties, are a perennial, time-tested favorite. Yet, the realm of bedding fabrics has expanded significantly since first sheet was put to mattress, introducing a range of choices beyond traditional cotton. Each fabric boasts unique attributes to the table, and these are reflected in any given sheet’s softness, durability, aesthetics, and cost. 

Diving into Cotton Sheets

Derived from the fibers of the cotton plant (!), cotton sheets remain the most popular choice largely due to their widespread availability. However, it’s essential to recognize that not all cotton is created equal, friends. Varieties like Egyptian, Pima, American upland cotton offer distinct levels of quality and durability. (One common trait among cotton sheets is their tendency to retain softness even after many washes—great news for any “hot sleepers” out there.)

  • Egyptian Cotton Sheets: Renowned for their premium quality and higher price tag, these sheets boast long fibers that result in lightweight and luxurious bedding.
  • Pima & Supima Cotton Sheets: Considered a more affordable luxury alternative, these sheets are made from good ol’ American-grown cotton.
  • American Upland Cotton Sheets: This budget-friendly option uses shorter fibers, resulting in less softness and durability compared to other cotton types.
  • Cotton Flannel Sheets: Perfect for cooler climates, these brushed cotton sheets provide a cozy experience.
  • Cotton Jersey Sheets: These knitted sheets offer comfort akin to your favorite t-shirt, but with a softer touch.
  • Polycotton Sheets: Blending polyester and cotton, these sheets provide easy maintenance and reduced wrinkles.
  • Polyester Microfiber Sheets: Ideal for those seeking affordable, low-maintenance bedding with less breathability.
  • Natural Fiber (Linen) Sheets: Eco-friendly and durable, linen sheets are perfect for allergy-prone individuals but tend to wrinkle easily.

The Art of Weaving

Often overlooked, the weave of sheets plays a crucial role in determining their texture and feel. Percale cotton sheets feature a crisp finish associated with luxury bedding. Combed cotton offers softness and durability through extensive processing, while sateen cotton boasts a silky feel due to its looser weave. In any case, understanding the weave is sneakily essential to ensuring your bed sheets align juuust-so with your comfort preferences.

Closing Thoughts

When you get down to it, picking the “right” bed sheets is about finding a precise balance between pragmatics and personal preference. -These are of course highly relative and subjective considerations, respectively, influenced by factors like budget constraints, comfort preferences, and sleep needs. But! Equipped as you now are with such unparalleled insight as (so humbly) provided above, thusly are you equipped now for confident navigation of the path leading to sheets that’ll provide commensurately unparalleled comfortand rest.


When doing your research on Mattress Peddlers, you’ll find we match up to top-quality mattress company criteria, and even go beyond it! We’ve been a family-owned business providing quality mattresses and furniture throughout Delaware and even beyond since 1994. We love working closely with our customers to figure out their needs and also offer free shipping throughout Lewes, Millsboro, Rehoboth Beach, Harbeson, and the surrounding areas of Delaware.

This entry was posted on Friday, August 25th, 2023 at 11:44 am. Both comments and pings are currently closed.